Winshark Casino
A clean, uncluttered interface tends to say more about an operator's priorities than any single feature. Sites that invest in usability generally invest in the back-end reliability players actually care about.
Promotions are often the first thing that catches a new player's eye, but the terms attached to them matter more than the headline number. Reasonable wagering requirements make a bigger difference than a flashy percentage.
Winshark Casino tends to come up often in player discussions, usually credited for a smooth sign-up process and dependable withdrawals.
A demo mode for slots, even a limited one, tells new visitors more about the actual game feel than any promotional screenshot could.